MgA. Karel Pivoňka
| Email: | karel.pivonka@avu.cz |
| Workplace: | Doctoral Research Department |
PhD Thesis: Thinking Images: A Cosmographic Interpretation of Timaeus and the Constitution
Supervisor: Mgr. Vojtěch Märc, Ph.D.
We have come to regard Plato as a detractor of the visual arts; he may even have been ‘the greatest enemy of art that Europe has ever produced’ (Nietzsche). Where does this image come from, and what motivation does it imply? Is there a specifically Platonic reason behind it, or merely a general tendency amongst philosophers to undermine and restrict the freedom of artists (Detienne, Danto)? What role does the ‘age-old dispute’ between philosophers and artists – which Plato himself formulated and described in Book X of the Republic – play in the background of this image?
The dissertation proceeds in two phases. First, I recall Plato’s ‘generous offer’ to artists within the political project described in the Republic: to participate in the education of citizens by depicting exemplary characters. And then I wish to vividly demonstrate just how difficult such an offer must have been for contemporary painters to accept.
In the second phase, I consider and elaborate on another of Plato’s offers and pitfalls. This is, in its own way, even more pressing, even though it is not explicitly stated: it lies in the very manner in which the artist’s own paintings are displayed. The images in the dialogues (such as the Allegory of the Cave) are captivating and tempt one to enter into their realm. I propose distinguishing these images as ‘didactic’, mathematical (mathéma is Greek for ‘teaching’), as opposed to the ‘imitative’, mimetic images of ordinary art. I believe that Plato regarded his mathematical images as a distinct second stage of artistic creation. Or perhaps as an intermediate, transitional and conciliatory stage between mimetic art and the teachings of philosophers and scientists.
The proposal for a multi-stage art form might sound far-fetched today, were it not for the fact that we might find a similar tendency in contemporary art schools: in the progression of a project’s scope across bachelor’s, master’s and doctoral studies. Moreover, at the highest level, there is an incentive towards ‘artistic research’, which perhaps merely continues the ‘old dispute’, with a slightly shifted prejudice regarding to whom thinking belongs and to whom it does not.
Can images think? Didactic images serve thinking; they are thinking images (a purpose-denoting adjective). Viewed from the opposite perspective, they are (or should be, according to Plato’s taste) beautifully framed by thoughts. Yet the frame does not stand entirely outside the pictorial event: it structures the space of everything within; in this respect, the image is thinking (an action-oriented and formative adjective).
Plato’s imagery tended towards parables and models of the world as a cosmos, the totality of all that is perceptible. I focus on several such images, such as the colourful ‘Spindle of Necessity’ in the Republic, or the most complex myth in the Timaeus: that of the world as a gigantic work of art. I examine the auxiliary role these images play, on the one hand in relation to cosmology (whether propaedeutic, methodological, or merely cosmetic), and on the other hand within the framework of Plato’s project of art, as well as the meaning they might have held for artists of the time. All these interests are encompassed and linked by the cosmographic method in the broad sense.
In a narrower sense, by ‘cosmography’ I mean the actual creation of second-order graphic images in the Platonic sense, or rather their reconstruction based on literary examples. This second approach was not addressed exclusively to writers; literary parables also captivate visual artists and inspire the cultivation of a new kind of image through a new graphic form. I base my work on what the written parables looked like in contemporary editions of the dialogues (the original scrolls have not survived; I have created a probable model). I add ‘non-book’ graphic forms, particularly those traditionally used in the figurative depiction of cosmogony. (By ‘graphics’ I mean the broad sense of the Greek term graphiké: writing, painting, drawing, sketching, engraving, printing.) Unusually, I rely on the form of a figurative diagram, as a kind of intermediate and conciliatory stage between written conceptual doctrine and mimetic figuration. It is difficult to reconcile a dispute rooted deep in the nature of the subject. How can one appease the visual artist in the face of a world that was apparently deliberately designed by the philosopher so that artists would remain outside the picture at the decisive moment?
This doctoral project re-evaluates Plato’s relationship with artists and art, including his own images; on the one hand, it justifies the philosopher’s nuanced and conditional favour towards painting, whilst on the other, it proposes the incorporation of cosmography into Plato’s picture of the world. The project will result in a series of loosely connected graphic scrolls.